Share this page
Trait Theory - Ralph Stogdill
A challenge to traditional trait-based leadership styles, as outlined by thought-leader Ralph Stogdill.
Table of contents
Challenges to Trait Theory: Stogdill 
Important research into leadership traits, and among the first to challenge traditional trait-based theory, was the work conducted by Ralph Stogdill.
Stogdill wrote a paper in 1948 (Personal Factors Associated with Leadership: a Survey of the Literature, Journal of Psychology) that cast doubt on trait theory.
Stogdill analysed data and findings from over a hundred leadership-related studies, across the following 27 groups of factors:
- Initiative, persistence, ambition, desire to excel
- Physique, energy, health
- Integrity and conviction
- Fluency of speech
- Happiness, sense of humour
- Academic results
- Emotional stability and control
- Social and economic status
- Judgement and decision (US-English, judgment)
- Social activity and mobility
- Insight (self, others, wider environment)
- Energy, daring and adventurousness
- Social skills (sociability, tact)
- Popularity, prestige
Stogdill found there wasn't much agreement on the key traits.
Indeed, it was clear that if all the findings were combined, the list became too long to be useful as a guide for selecting future leaders.
Stogdill's conclusions actually still hold firm today, and show no sign of being undermined in the future.
This extract from Organizational Behaviour (1985), by David Buchanan and Andrzej Huczynski, reflects very well modern thinking about this:
"The problem [in attempting to classify/measure leadership capability] is that research has been unable to identify a common, agreed set of [leadership] attributes. Successful leaders seem to defy classification and measurement from this perspective."
Stogdill was one of the first to point out that a person doesn't become an effective leader just because he or she has certain traits.
He argued that a successful leader's characteristics must be relevant to the demands of the leadership situation - that is, the specific challenges faced and the abilities, hopes, values and concerns of the followers.
Ratings are brand new to BusinessBalls, let us know what you think!